Forums General discussion Suggestions for Gathers

Suggestions for Gathers

semi
Noavatar
Posts
14
Location
Florida, United States of America
Joined
5 December 2012
9 October 2014 - 20:21 CEST
#1
With the amount of time that can span between gathers filling we are running into a huge problem with users being away, closing the tab, or forgetting about the gather and AFK'ing without leaving. I have a few suggestions that could make the system more robust. Some of these may be more difficult to implement and be less beneficial.

1. Remove a user if they close the tab, use an `onbeforeunload` event to alert the user that this will happen
2. Highlight users that have been inactive (show as a lighter gray color) so we know they might be AFK
3. Alert AFK users and if they don't respond remove from gather
4. Use a steam bot to notify users in Steam when a gather is filled / they've been picked as captains

I will honestly help implement these if the admins agree with these and need someone to do so. I'm a web developer by trade.
Send PM
http://www.twitch.tv/semihandy
Pelargir
5291
We're grumpy
Posts
452
Location
Lyon, France
Joined
6 April 2013
9 October 2014 - 21:09 CEST
#2
semi says
With the amount of time that can span between gathers filling we are running into a huge problem with users being away, closing the tab, or forgetting about the gather and AFK'ing without leaving. I have a few suggestions that could make the system more robust. Some of these may be more difficult to implement and be less beneficial.

1. Remove a user if they close the tab, use an `onbeforeunload` event to alert the user that this will happen
2. Highlight users that have been inactive (show as a lighter gray color) so we know they might be AFK
3. Alert AFK users and if they don't respond remove from gather
4. Use a steam bot to notify users in Steam when a gather is filled / they've been picked as captains

I will honestly help implement these if the admins agree with these and need someone to do so. I'm a web developer by trade.


We need to talk about that but someone able to make such changes would be awesome.
Send PM
“It's a dangerous business, Frodo, going out your door. You step onto the road, and if you don't keep your feet, there's no knowing where you might be swept off to.”
Simba
2852
Posts
311
Location
United States of America
Joined
24 June 2012
9 October 2014 - 21:35 CEST
#3
Correct, I am unsure if we have any capable developers who can make such changes to the website's ruby rails code.
Send PM
semi
Noavatar
Posts
14
Location
Florida, United States of America
Joined
5 December 2012
9 October 2014 - 22:17 CEST
#4
Simba says
Correct, I am unsure if we have any capable developers who can make such changes to the website's ruby rails code.


Rails?! *cries* ... In any case, I can help, even if I'm not a fan of Rails.

Does that mean you guys agree that the features would be nice to have? :)
Send PM
http://www.twitch.tv/semihandy
Zefram
3639
Posts
235
Location
United States of America
Joined
16 November 2012
9 October 2014 - 22:56 CEST
#5
I'm all for these changes (except maybe 4) and even want more changes to the gather system.

I'd prefer to have a pick 'em style like the reddit gathers where commanders volunteer and are choosing teams rather than the "best" players. At least you know there will always be a comm for each team and it's a person who wants to command rather than just volunteered by their gather team.

semi, get in touch with me. I'll talk to jiriki and csm to see what we can do. Thanks for the help and suggestions.
Send PM
www.twitch.tv/Zefram0911
semi
Noavatar
Posts
14
Location
Florida, United States of America
Joined
5 December 2012
9 October 2014 - 23:49 CEST
#6
Yeah, #4 was a bit of a stretch and not something I'd even want to implement :). I'll get in touch via Steam!

Thanks everyone for listening.
Send PM
http://www.twitch.tv/semihandy
csm
97
Posts
2
Location
Leeds, UK, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland
Joined
7 May 2005
10 October 2014 - 00:44 CEST
#7
semi says
Yeah, #4 was a bit of a stretch and not something I'd even want to implement :). I'll get in touch via Steam!

Thanks everyone for listening.


Hi semi,

It would be great if you could lend a hand. Please checkout https://github.com/ENSL/ensl.org/tree/develop if you'd like to open a pull request and i'll get them merged.

The site is currently running Ruby 2.1.3 on Rails 3.2.

The plan was to add better test coverage, refactor and at least upgrade to Rails 4.0 but lack of time is currently the blocker.

Cheers
Send PM
semi
Noavatar
Posts
14
Location
Florida, United States of America
Joined
5 December 2012
10 October 2014 - 17:14 CEST
#8
csm says
semi says
Yeah, #4 was a bit of a stretch and not something I'd even want to implement :). I'll get in touch via Steam!

Thanks everyone for listening.


Hi semi,

It would be great if you could lend a hand. Please checkout https://github.com/ENSL/ensl.org/tree/develop if you'd like to open a pull request and i'll get them merged.

The site is currently running Ruby 2.1.3 on Rails 3.2.

The plan was to add better test coverage, refactor and at least upgrade to Rails 4.0 but lack of time is currently the blocker.

Cheers


Oh! I didn't know the ensl.org code was already open source. Cool! :D
Send PM
http://www.twitch.tv/semihandy
Mega
1942
pubstars
Posts
225
Location
Germany
Joined
28 September 2009
12 October 2014 - 14:00 CEST
#9
semi says
With the amount of time that can span between gathers filling we are running into a huge problem with users being away, closing the tab, or forgetting about the gather and AFK'ing without leaving. I have a few suggestions that could make the system more robust. Some of these may be more difficult to implement and be less beneficial.

1. Remove a user if they close the tab, use an `onbeforeunload` event to alert the user that this will happen
2. Highlight users that have been inactive (show as a lighter gray color) so we know they might be AFK
3. Alert AFK users and if they don't respond remove from gather
4. Use a steam bot to notify users in Steam when a gather is filled / they've been picked as captains

I will honestly help implement these if the admins agree with these and need someone to do so. I'm a web developer by trade.



Good ideas but

Number 1)
the "remove user if they close tab" is too much
im closeing my browser to play ns2 cause its so resource hungry.
what means i open the gather page in the steam browser.

So can you remove them if they didnt open the page again in like idk 5 minutes instead of instantly.
(some people even restart their pcs cause of various problems)


Number 2)
Not sure how this is going to motivate people to join a gather if they see a lot gray people.
I dont think thats a good idea.

Number4)
I like this Idea a LOT
it helps to prevent number 2 and 3 and that is what you truely want instead of removing people from the gather.


Also we posted about the gather a lot earlier and i gonna highlight my concept again cause i think it might give some inspiration:
www.ensl.org/topics/1165#post_14762

so far good job and thanks for going it on.
Send PM
New Reply
Forums General discussion Suggestions for Gathers